Contents
Overview of Q1 Insurance Stock Performance
The insurance industry plays a critical role in absorbing and diversifying risk, offering financial protection against various life events such as health issues, property damage, and liability claims. The profitability of insurance companies is largely driven by underwriting—where they collect more in premiums than they pay out in claims—and the investment of their ‘float.’ This cyclical industry benefits from strong pricing power during ‘hard markets’ and higher interest rates that boost investment income. However, it also faces challenges such as low interest rates, rising claims costs due to climate-related disasters, inflation, and increased litigation expenses.
AI adoption is transforming the sector by improving underwriting through advanced data analysis and reducing operational costs via automation. Despite these advancements, the industry continues to navigate headwinds in ‘soft markets’ with lower pricing power and weaker investment returns.
Mixed Q1 Results for Insurance Stocks
Among the 58 insurance stocks we track, Q1 results were mixed. On average, revenues exceeded analysts’ expectations by 1.1%, but share prices have declined overall, with an average drop of 1.3% since the latest earnings reports.
Hartford (NYSE:HIG)
Hartford, known for its iconic stag logo dating back to 1810, offers property and casualty insurance, group benefits, and investment products across the U.S. In Q1, the company reported revenues of $6.81 billion, reflecting a 6.1% year-over-year increase. However, this fell short of analysts’ expectations by 2.3%. The company also missed book value per share estimates, though its EPS aligned with analyst projections.
Despite these challenges, The Hartford’s Chairman and CEO Christopher Swift highlighted a strong start to 2025, with a trailing 12-month core earnings ROE of 16.2 percent. Since the earnings report, the stock has dropped 4.8% and currently trades at $121.87.
Root (NASDAQ:ROOT)
Root, a technology-driven auto insurance company, uses mobile apps and data science to assess individual driving behavior and price policies accordingly. In Q1, the company reported revenues of $349.4 million, a 37.1% year-over-year increase, significantly exceeding analysts’ expectations by 9.1%. It also beat EPS and net premiums earned estimates.
Despite these strong results, the market reacted negatively, causing the stock to fall 12.1% since the report. It now trades at $123.30. Investors are debating whether this dip presents an opportunity to buy.
Equitable Holdings (NYSE:EQH)
Equitable Holdings, one of America’s oldest financial institutions, provides retirement planning, asset management, and life insurance products through its franchises, Equitable and AllianceBernstein. In Q1, the company reported revenues of $3.78 billion, up 4% year over year, but this still fell short of analysts’ expectations by 5.7%. The quarter was marked by a significant miss in EPS estimates.
Since the earnings report, the stock has remained flat, trading at $53.18.
Radian Group (NYSE:RDN)
Radian Group, founded during the housing boom of 1977, offers mortgage insurance and real estate services. In Q1, the company reported revenues of $318.1 million, a 3.4% decrease year over year, which came in 3% below analyst expectations. However, its EPS matched analyst estimates.
Despite the softer performance, the stock has risen 5.4% since the report and currently trades at $35.01.
AIG (NYSE:AIG)
AIG, with roots dating back to 1919 in Shanghai, China, is a global insurance provider operating in over 200 countries. In Q1, the company reported flat revenues of $6.78 billion, matching analyst expectations. While it beat EPS estimates, it missed on book value per share.
The stock has gained 2.9% since the report and now trades at $83.07.
Market Update and Outlook
The Federal Reserve’s rate hikes in 2022 and 2023 helped cool inflation to near the 2% target, achieving a soft landing without significantly impacting economic growth. The stock market performed well in 2024, supported by recent rate cuts and a surge following Donald Trump’s presidential election win. However, the outlook for 2025 remains uncertain due to potential trade policy changes and corporate tax discussions, which could affect business confidence and growth.
Investors looking for stable, high-performing stocks can consider adding companies with strong fundamentals to their watchlists. These firms are positioned for growth regardless of macroeconomic or political shifts.
StockStory is expanding and hiring equity analysts and marketing professionals. If you’re passionate about the markets and AI, explore open roles and contribute to the company’s growth.
